Journal of Cytology
Home About us Ahead of print Instructions Submission Subscribe Advertise Contact e-Alerts Login 
Users Online:99
  Print this page  Email this page Small font sizeDefault font sizeIncrease font size

ORIGINAL ARTICLE Table of Contents   
Year : 2010  |  Volume : 27  |  Issue : 1  |  Page : 1-7
Application of pattern analysis in fine needle aspiration of solitary nodule of thyroid

Department of Pathology, VMKV Medical College, Salem, India

Click here for correspondence address and email

Date of Web Publication23-Jul-2010


Background : Various methods are used to arrive at a conclusive diagnosis of thyroid lesions on fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). Systemic pattern analysis is one such that can be used to analyze the lesions and divide them into individual categories.
Aims : To study the application of pattern analysis in the interpretation of solitary thyroid nodule (STN).
Materials and Methods : Two hundred and nineteen cases of fine needle aspiration cytology of STN were reviewed along with histopathological correlation. Smears were classified based on primary and secondary patterns. Predominant pattern (primary) was identified and lesion categorized. This was followed by identifying the next dominant pattern (secondary) and recategorization. Cytological diagnosis based on primary and secondary patterns was correlated with the histopathological diagnosis.
Results : Based on pattern analysis, the study had a sensitivity of 66.7% and specificity of 98.9%. The positive predictive value and negative predictive value were 88.9% and 96% respectively and the overall diagnostic accuracy was 95.4%.
Conclusions : The present study demonstrates the feasibility and applicability of pattern analysis in diagnosing thyroid lesions by FNAC, which could be easily reproducible.

Keywords: Fine needle aspiration; pattern analysis; solitary thyroid nodule

How to cite this article:
Lingegowda JB, Muddegowda PH, Kumar N R, Kurpad R R. Application of pattern analysis in fine needle aspiration of solitary nodule of thyroid. J Cytol 2010;27:1-7

How to cite this URL:
Lingegowda JB, Muddegowda PH, Kumar N R, Kurpad R R. Application of pattern analysis in fine needle aspiration of solitary nodule of thyroid. J Cytol [serial online] 2010 [cited 2022 Jun 24];27:1-7. Available from:

   Introduction Top

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is now accepted as a cost-effective procedure in the initial assessment and management of thyroid enlargement. It is minimally invasive, has a low complication rate and offers non-operative diagnosis for most of the thyroid lesions. It has been shown that FNAC is highly successful in triaging patients with solitary thyroid nodule (STN) into operative and non-operative groups. [1],[2]

Clinically detectable thyroid nodules occur in 4-10% of the population. The majority of the nodules are non-neoplastic. Among the neoplastic lesions, only 5-30% are malignant and require surgical intervention. The main goal of thyroid FNA is to identify the STN that require surgery and reduce the overall number of thyroidectomies for patients with benign disease. [3]

Several studies have confirmed the accuracy and reliability of FNAC in the differentiation between relatively small number of malignant thyroid nodules and the larger percentage of nodules that are benign. [4]

The numerous diagnostic procedures currently available improve the anatomic, pathologic, radiological and functional assessment of thyroid nodules but may also lead to unjustified increase in cost with little practical gain, if not used rationally. As most of the hospitals lack some of these ancillary diagnostic investigations, FNAC is still regarded as the single most accurate and cost-effective procedure. [5]

Despite the many sites and many types of tumours that are aspirated, there are a limited number of patterns that are observed in the aspirated material. However, the frequency, significance and difference of each pattern varies with the site. [6]

Many authors have used various methods to arrive at a conclusive diagnosis of thyroid lesions on FNA. Here, we propose a partially modified method based on pattern analysis, as suggested by Andrew A. Renshaw, [6] to analyse the lesions and divide them into individual categories.

   Materials and Methods Top

Material for the present study was obtained retrospectively over a period of four years from the archives of the Department of Pathology, VMKV Medical College, Salem. Majority of the aspirations were performed in the department itself by cytopathologists. Before aspiration, physical examination of the thyroid gland was carried out to assess its size, mobility during deglutition, its nodularity and evidence of clinical signs of thyrotoxicosis. Neck nodes were also palpated for enlargement.

Aspiration was performed using disposable 10 ml syringe with a 23 G needle and syringe holder. Non-aspiration technique was also used in some cases to reduce contamination of specimen. The number of passes was kept to a minimum to minimize hemorrhage, and was usually two to three. Each case had a minimum of three smears and was stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H and E), papanicolaou (PAP) and giemsa stains.

A total of 1,346 thyroid aspirations were performed during this period, of which 359 cases were of clinically detected STN, with 233 cases having a follow-up surgery with histopathological correlation. These latter cases were taken for this study. Cases in which sample was inadequate were excluded from the study. In total, 219 cases formed the crux of the study.

Each slide was examined by two different cytologists with a difference in experience of 15 years. They were asked to identify the patterns [Table 1] and make a provisional diagnosis.

The final provisional diagnosis was given out in the following manner: [1]

  1. Benign
  2. Atypia of undetermined significance (AUS)
  3. Neoplasm
  4. Suspicious for malignancy
  5. Malignant

The cytologists were asked to identify the predominant pattern (primary) first and then give out a diagnosis and then to identify the next dominant pattern (secondary) and give the combined pattern diagnosis. The variation between primary, secondary pattern and final cytological diagnosis was matched with the final histopathological diagnosis for correlation and statistical data were prepared.

Statistical Analysis

For each correlation, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and diagnostic accuracy were calculated. Interobserver variation was assessed by kappa measure of agreement.

   Results Top

Two hundred and nineteen (219) cases of STN aspirates with histopathological confirmation were evaluated by two observers based on the primary and secondary patterns. For convenience of discussion, the lesions were categorized into eight (8) groups based on primary pattern, as shown in [Table 2].

Of the 219 cases, 195 were benign, consisting of nodular colloid goitre (n=116), adenomatoid nodule (n=13), Hashimotos thyroiditis (n=20), Hurthle cell adenoma (n=9) and follicular adenoma (n=37).

There were 24 malignant lesions, including papillary carcinoma (n=18), medullary carcinoma (n=2) and anaplastic carcinoma (n=4).

In the present study, the total numbers of cases of true positives (malignant) were 16, true negatives (benign) were 193, false positives were two and false negatives were eight.

Based on pattern analysis, the statistics for benign and malignant lesions were sensitivity of 66.7%, specificity of 98.9%, positive predictive value of 88.9%, negative predictive value of 96% and diagnostic accuracy of 95.4%.

Interobserver variation

Unanimous agreement between the two reviewers was observed in 187 (85.38%) cases, including 124 benign, 11 AUS, 37 neoplasm and 15 malignancies. Six cases were diagnosed as benign by one reviewer and as suspicious for malignancy or AUS by the other, and all turned out to be malignant lesions histologically. Sixteen cases diagnosed as AUS by reviewer one, were diagnosed as benign or neoplasm by the other, including 12 histologically proven benign lesions and four malignant lesions. Seven cases were diagnosed as neoplasm by one reviewer and as benign by the other, where three cases turned out to be benign, two cases of adenoma and two malignancies on histopathology. Three cases were diagnosed as malignant by one reviewer and as suspicious for malignancy by the other, which turned out to be one case of malignancy and two cases of adenoma on histopathology.

Benign, AUS and neoplasm were categorized under benign lesions, while suspicious for malignancy and malignant were included under malignant lesions. Considering this, the kappa measure of agreement between benign and malignant lesions between the two reviewers was found to be κ = 0.85.

   Discussion Top

Our findings illustrate the value of applying a systematic pattern analysis to evaluate the thyroid cytology smear. The present study confirms that assessment of pattern, when applying both primary and secondary pattern, has enough accuracy for the surgeon to triage into operative and non-operative cases.

In Group I [Figure 1], the predominant pattern was colloid-rich background followed by various other secondary patterns, like Hurthle cells (common in colloid goitre), macrophages (cystic lesions) and follicular cells in sheets/scattered/microfollicles. Microfollicles are rarely seen in colloid goitre and need to be differentiated from adenomatoid nodule and follicular neoplasm. In difficult cases, diagnosis of AUS is usually preferred. Macrofollicular adenomas will be usually diagnosed as colloid nodule as more colloid is seen, while thyroid nodules with microfollicles are named as "follicular neoplasm" without knowing the status of encapsulation. Histopathologically, adenomatoid nodule is often incompletely encapsulated, composed of dilated follicles lined with tall cylindrical cells with small follicles and scant or absent colloid. Because of the overlapping features of microfollicles and scant colloid, it is difficult to separate follicular neoplasm from adenomatoid nodule on aspirate. [1],[7],[8],[9]

In Group II [Figure 2], the predominant pattern was biphasic, with lymphocyte-rich or Hurthle cell-rich background as secondary patterns. When the Hurthle cells form the major component, diagnosis of neoplasm is usually favored. One case of Hashimotos was grouped in this category because the lesion was a Hurthle cell-rich Hashimotos thyroiditis. Lymphocyte-rich background would have been supportive. Other authors have had a similar experience in this regard. [10]

In Group III [Figure 3], the predominant pattern was Hurthle cell rich followed by other background patterns, like colloid-rich background (benign diagnosis), hemorrhagic background (neoplasm) and lymphocytic background (lymphocytic/Hashimotos thyroiditis). A hemorrhagic background always points to a highly vascular proliferative lesion and has been shown in other cases in the past, which helped in diagnosing the lesion. If aspirates contain more than 75% Hurthle cells, the possibility of a Hurthle cell neoplasm should be considered, in the absence of which non-neoplastic lesions are to be suspected. [10],[11]

In Group IV [Figure 4], the predominant pattern was a macrophage-rich pattern with various other secondary patterns. One case of adenomatoid nodule was inadvertently called as neoplasm; this was probably due to the proliferative nature of the lesion. Cytological differentiation is very difficult in these cases due to overlapping cytological features. [7],[9],[10],[12]

In Group V [Figure 5], monotonous crowding was the predominant pattern followed by increased cell size and nuclear enlargement (enlarged oval nucleus pattern). Nuclear grooves and intranuclear inclusions were also commonly seen. All cases were reported accurately probably due to the crowding pattern and nuclear details. [1],[7] Two cases of follicular neoplasm were overdiagnosed as malignant probably due to increased cellularity and nuclear atypia on cytology.

In Group VI [Figure 6], a microfollicle-poor pattern was predominant, with various secondary patterns. Two cases of papillary carcinoma were missed in a colloid-rich background. Histopathology of these cases showed the presence of microscopic foci of papillary carcinoma in one case and possible cystic change in the other. The cause of detection/diagnosis failure was possibly the presence of small minute foci of a papillary thyroid carcinoma that was missed during aspiration and presence of degenerative foci/interpretation error in another. One case turned out to be follicular adenoma probably due to aspiration performed over the colloid-rich macrofollicular areas of the neoplasm. Similar cases have been encountered by others. Detailed clinical examination and multiple aspirations from different sites would be a possible remedial measure. [1],[2],[12],[13]

In Group VII [Figure 7], a microfollicle-rich pattern was predominant. Two cases with hemorrhagic background were diagnosed as neoplasm on FNAC, which turned out to be a follicular variant of papillary carcinoma on histopathology. The presence of follicular structure led to misinterpretation, as has been encountered by others. Four cases with nuclear enlargement (enlarged oval nucleus pattern) were correctly identified as papillary carcinoma. Colloid goitre often forms a part of this group possibly due to difficulty in differentiating between follicular neoplasm and nodular goitre. The most important clue in diagnosing follicular neoplasm is "abundant blood containing rare microfollicles". Abundant blood is indicative of high microvessel density in the nodule. An exceedingly bloody aspirate containing microfollicles, even if few in number, is a cytologic clue to follicular neoplasm. [12],[13],[14]

Performing repeated FNA of persistent nodules is considered by some investigators as a useful way for correcting an initial false-negative diagnosis. Overlapping criteria between adenomatoid nodule and follicular neoplasm could have led to increased diagnosis of AUS on cytology. [3],[7],[9]

Follicular neoplasm forms a gray zone, with the differential diagnoses including follicular carcinoma, follicular variant of papillary carcinoma (FVPC), follicular adenoma and adenomatoid nodule. Over the past several decades, iodide supplementation to food supplies in many parts of the world has been followed by a corresponding decrease in the incidence of follicular thyroid carcinoma. [5],[12]

In Group VIII [Figure 8], a pleomorphic pattern was predominant, with anaplastic carcinoma being the most common diagnosis. Presence of pink amyloid-like material in the background led to diagnosis of medullary carcinoma in two cases. Presumptive diagnosis of medullary carcinoma of the thyroid based on pleomorphism and amyloid has been described previously. Amyloid must be distinguished from other pink amorphous-appearing material, including fibrin, collagen fibres and non-amyloid kappa light chain protein. [7],[15]

AUS is defined as a heterogeneous category that may be appropriate to use for architectural or cytological atypia on a compromised specimen. The risk of malignancy is limited to 5-10%. In the present study, AUS category was high (12.32%), probably due to overlapping findings that were not convincingly benign, but neither sufficient enough to call it as neoplasm/suspicious for malignancy. Limiting the use of this category as suggested by National Cancer Institute (USA) to <7% is desirable because all cases of AUS turned out to be benign on histopathology in our study, thereby reducing the purpose of FNA, which is to limit the number of benign lesions under the scalpel. Studies have shown that eliminating the AUS category increases the false-negative rate. [8],[16] The false-negative error rate in our study was 0.93%.

The increased number of AUS in our study might be due to selection of cases having cytohistopathological correlation and increased number of cases being taken for surgery with diagnosis of AUS. We have now suggested follow-up in such cases to our clinicians and to defer surgery till repeat FNAC is performed, as there is an increased likelihood that subtle evidence of malignancy may become obvious during the second FNA and exuberant reactive changes on the initial smear may diminish after several months following first FNA. [16]

The major diagnostic problems are due to use of marginally adequate specimen with diagnosis of malignancy based on just one or two atypical cytological features or overlapping cytological features of various lesions. The efficiency of FNA is responsible for a marked increase in the rate of malignancies found at surgery. The incidence of false-positive error rate for malignancy was zero in the present study. The different statistical values indicating the diagnostic efficacies observed in the present study can be well compared with other studies [Table 3]. [3],[12],[17],[18],[19],[20],[21]

Considering the data of accuracy, it is evident that pattern analysis is highly accurate and has a low rate of false-negative and false-positive diagnosis.

Our study, to the best of our knowledge, is the first comprehensive systematic attempt to use pattern analysis in the interpretation of FNA cytology in STN.

   Conclusion Top

FNA cytology is a cost-effective and useful first-line screening and diagnostic technique for the evaluation of STN. Diagnostic accuracy is very high, with a high specificity and sensitivity, thus reducing the number of surgeries. Application of pattern analysis has also allowed the same accuracy and is easily reproducible. We recommend this method in the interpretation of thyroid FNA. Pattern analysis can be applied for diffuse thyroid lesions as well and lesions of other organs too. Our study demonstrates the feasibility and applicability of pattern analysis in interpreting STN lesions.

   References Top

1.Layfield LJ, Cibas ES, Gharib H, Mandel SJ. Thyroid aspiration cytology: Current status. CA Cancer J Clin 2009;59:99-110.   Back to cited text no. 1  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
2.Guhamallick M, Sengupta S, Bhattacharya NK, Basu N, Roy S, Ghosh AK, Chowdhury M. Cytodiagnosis of thyroid lesions-usefulness and pitfalls: A study of 288 cases. J Cytol 2008;25:6-9.   Back to cited text no. 2    Medknow Journal  
3.Bukhari MH, Niazi S, Hanif G, Qureshi SS, Munir M, Hasan M, et al. An updated audit of fine needle aspiration cytology procedure of solitary thyroid nodule. Diagn Cytopathol 2008;36:104-12.  Back to cited text no. 3  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
4.Al-Rikabi AC, Al-Omran M, Cheema M, El-Khwsky F, Al-Nuaim A. Pattern of thyroid lesions and role of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNA) in the management of thyroid enlargement: A retrospective study from a teaching hospital in Riyadh. APMIS 1998;106:1069-74.   Back to cited text no. 4  [PUBMED]    
5.El Hag IA, Kollur SM, Chiedozi LC. The role of FNA in the initial management of thyroid lesions: 7-year experience in a district general hospital. Cytopathology 2003;14:126-30.   Back to cited text no. 5  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
6.Renshaw AA. Thyroid. In: Renshaw AA, editor. Aspiration Cytology - A pattern recognition approach. 1 st edition. China: Elsevier Saunders; 2005. p. 331-76.  Back to cited text no. 6      
7.Davidson HG, Campora RG. Thyroid. In: Bibbo M, editor. Comprehensive cytopathology. 3 rd ed. China: Elsevier Saunders; 2009. p. 633-70.  Back to cited text no. 7      
8.Baloch ZW, LiVolsi VA, Asa SL, Rosai J, Merino MJ, Randolph G, et al. Diagnostic terminology and morphologic criteria for cytologic diagnosis of thyroid lesions: A synopsis of the National Cancer Institute Thyroid Fine-Needle Aspiration State of the Science Conference. Diagn Cytopathol 2008;36:425-37.   Back to cited text no. 8  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
9.Ylagan LR, Farkas T, Dehner LP. Fine needle aspiration of the thyroid: A cytohistologic correlation and study of discrepant cases. Thyroid 2004;14:35-41.   Back to cited text no. 9      
10.Jogai S, Al-Jassar A, Temmim L, Dey P, Adesina AO, Amanguno HG. Fine needle aspiration cytology of the thyroid: A cytohistologic study with evaluation of discordant cases. Acta Cytol 2005;49:483-8.   Back to cited text no. 10      
11.Kini SR, Miller JM, Hamburger JI. Cytopathology of Hurthle cell lesions of the thyroid gland by fine needle aspiration. Acta Cytol 1981;25:647-52.   Back to cited text no. 11  [PUBMED]    
12.Baloch ZW, Fleisher S, LiVolsi VA, Gupta PK. Diagnosis of "follicular neoplasm": A gray zone in thyroid fine-needle aspiration cytology. Diagn Cytopathol 2002;26:41-4.   Back to cited text no. 12  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
13.Kapur U, Wojcik EM. Follicular neoplasm of the thyroid-vanishing cytologic diagnosis? Diagn Cytopathol 2007;35:525-8.   Back to cited text no. 13  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
14.Yang GC, Liebeskind D, Messina AV. Should cytopathologists stop reporting follicular neoplasms on fine-needle aspiration of the thyroid? Cancer 2003;99:69-74.   Back to cited text no. 14  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
15.Halliday BE, Silverman JF, Finley JL. Fine-needle aspiration cytology of amyloid associated with nonneoplastic and malignant lesions. Diagn Cytopathol 1998;18:270-5.   Back to cited text no. 15  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
16.Nayar R, Ivanovic M. The indeterminate thyroid fine needle aspiration: Experience from an academic center using terminology similar to that proposed in the 2007 National Cancer Institute Thyroid Fine Needle Aspiration State of the Science Conference. Cancer Cytopathol 2009;117:195-202.  Back to cited text no. 16  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
17.Ravetto C, Colombo L, Dottorini ME. Usefulness of fine-needle aspiration in the diagnosis of thyroid carcinoma: A retrospective study of 37,895 patients. Cancer 2000;90:357-63.   Back to cited text no. 17  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
18.Sangalli G, Serio G, Zampatti C, Bellotti M, Lomuscio G. Fine needle aspiration cytology of the thyroid: A comparison of 5469 cytological and final histological diagnoses. Cytopathology 2006;17:245-50.  Back to cited text no. 18  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
19.Lopez LH, Canto JA, Herrera MF, Gamboa-Dominguez A, Rivera R, Gonzalez O, et al. Efficacy of fine-needle aspiration biopsy of thyroid nodules: Experience of a Mexican institution. World J Surg 1997;21:408-11.  Back to cited text no. 19  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
20.Flanagan MB, Ohori NP, Carty SE, Hunt JL. Repeat thyroid nodule fine-needle aspiration in patients with initial benign cytologic results. Am J Clin Pathol 2006;125:698-702.  Back to cited text no. 20  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  
21.Chao TC, Lin JD, Chao HH, Hsueh C, Chen MF. Surgical treatment of solitary thyroid nodules via fine-needle aspiration biopsy and frozen-section analysis. Ann Surg Oncol 2007;14:712-8.  Back to cited text no. 21  [PUBMED]  [FULLTEXT]  

Correspondence Address:
Jyothi B Lingegowda
Assistant Prof. of Pathology, Vinayaka Missions Medical College, Seeragapadi, Salem - 636 306, Tamil Nadu
Login to access the Email id

Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None

DOI: 10.4103/0970-9371.66688

Rights and Permissions


  [Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4], [Figure 5], [Figure 6], [Figure 7], [Figure 8]

  [Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]

This article has been cited by
1 Role of Imprint Cytology in Diagnosis of Thyroid Lesions
Abilash K Prasad, Chellaiah Petchiappan Ganesh Babu, Chetan Anand, Kathirvelu Shanmugasamy
World Journal of Endocrine Surgery. 2019; 11(2): 49
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
2 Effectiveness of the Pattern-Based Approach in the Cytodiagnosis of Salivary Gland Lesions
K. Amita, S. Vijay Shankar, M. Sanjay, B.M. Sarvesh
Acta Cytologica. 2016; 60(2): 107
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
Dinesh Kumar Singh,Ravindra Kumar Shrivas,Paricharak D.G.,Nitu Nigam,Sanjay Kumar Nigam
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental sciences. 2013; 2(36): 6903
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
4 Role of multiparameter analysis of AgNORs in FNA smears of thyroid swellings in differentiating benign and malignant lesions
Hossain, M.I. and Hassan, M.Q. and Bhattacharjee, P. and Ahamad, M.S.U. and Rahman, Z.
Pathology Research International. 2012; 2012(908106)
5 Risk factors for malignancy in patients with solitary thyroid nodules and their impact on the management
Tai, J.D. and Yang, J.D. and Wu, S.C. and Wang, B.W. and Chang, C.J.
Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics. 2012; 8(3): 379-383
6 Role of Multiparameter Analysis of AgNORs in FNA Smears of Thyroid Swellings in Differentiating Benign and Malignant Lesions
Mohammad Ismail Hossain,Md Quamrul Hassan,Pradip Bhattacharjee,M. Shahab Uddin Ahamad,Zillur Rahman
Pathology Research International. 2012; 2012: 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
7 Fine needle aspiration cytology as the primary diagnostic tool in thyroid enlargement
Sengupta, A. and Pal, R. and Kar, S. and Zaman, F.A. and Sengupta, S. and Pal, S.
Journal of Natural Science, Biology and Medicine. 2011; 2(1): 113-118


    Similar in PUBMED
   Search Pubmed for
   Search in Google Scholar for
 Related articles
    Email Alert *
    Add to My List *
* Registration required (free)  

    Materials and Me...
    Article Figures
    Article Tables

 Article Access Statistics
    PDF Downloaded521    
    Comments [Add]    
    Cited by others 7    

Recommend this journal